| Offense | First Team | Second Team |
| QB | Eli Grant, Sr., Case Western | Scott Kirchoff, Sr., Bethel |
| RB | David McNeal, Sr., Kings Point | Fletcher Ladd, Sr., Amherst |
| RB | Tony Sutton, Jr., Wooster | Brad Hodapp, Sr., Wartburg |
| WR | Walter Hays, Sr., Howard Payne | Justin Salton, Sr., Franklin & Marshall |
| WR | Blake Elliott, Sr., St. John's | Mark Bartosic, Sr., Susquehanna |
| TE | Mike Healy, Sr., Chicago | Matt Moskosky, Jr., Hardin-Simmons |
| OL | Larry Kinnard, Sr., Mount Union | James Hoxworth, Sr., Wheaton |
| OL | Matthew Atkins, Sr., Thomas More | Jared Carillo, Sr., Trinity (Conn.) |
| OL | James Flowers, Sr., Trinity (Texas) | Billy Joe Murray, Sr., Willamette |
| OL | Charlie Dutra, Sr., Menlo | Chris Ahrens, Sr., UW-La Crosse |
| OL | Ben Knepper, Sr., UW-Stout | Brent Miller, Sr., Mount Union |
| Defense | ||
| DL | Blair Hammer, Sr., Wabash | Joe Kersten, Sr., UW-Stout |
| DL | Vince King, Sr., Wartburg | Jarrod Smith, Trinity (Texas) |
| DL | Joe Indriolo, Sr., John Carroll | Antoine Dillard, Sr., Mount Union |
| DL | Jeremy Hood, Sr., St. John's | Tiko Williams, Sr., Randolph-Macon |
| LB | Ron Swearingin, Sr., Capital | Casey Carlson, Sr., Pacific Lutheran |
| LB | Jermaine Taylor, Sr., Bridgewater | Matt O'Bryant, Sr., Millsaps |
| LB | Cam McCambrigde, Sr., St. John's | Robert Truman, Sr., Ithaca |
| DB | Kennard Davis, Jr., Thiel | Ron Shiels, Sr., Adrian |
| DB | Greg Koch, Sr., Baldwin-Wallace | Kyle Hausler, So., Capital |
| DB | Ray Lions, Sr., Linfield | Michael Drach, Sr., Wheaton |
| DB | Alex Hansen, Jr., Hardin-Simmons | John Woock, Jr., Washington U. |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Greg Switaj, Sr., Springfield | Chad Wurth, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| P | Scott Verhalen, Sr., East Texas Baptist | Mike Donnenwerth, Sr., Simpson |
| RET | Blake Elliott, Sr., St. John's | Jeremy Lynch, Sr., Brockport State |