Dec 14, 2018
D3football.com Offensive Player of the Year: Jackson Erdmann, QB, St. John's.
D3football.com Defensive Player of the Year: Louis Berry, CB, Mount Union.
D3football.com Coach of the Year: Jim Margraff, Johns Hopkins.
| First team offense | ||||
| Pos. | Player | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| QB | Jackson Erdmann | St. John's | Jr. | Rosemount, Minn. |
| RB | Markeith Miller | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Garland, Texas |
| RB | Le'Anthony Reasnover | Eureka | Sr. | Momence, Ill. |
| WR | Justin Hill | Mount Union | Jr. | Circleville, Ohio |
| WR | Richard Johnson | East Texas Baptist | Sr. | Cleveland, Texas |
| TE | Ryan Curtiss | Muhlenberg | Jr. | Franklin Lakes, N.J. |
| T | Sam Shook | Ohio Northern | Sr. | New Philadelphia, Ohio |
| G | Dan Greenheck | St. John's | Jr. | St. Paul, Minn. |
| C | Nate Trewyn | UW-Whitewater | Sr. | Janesville, Wis. |
| G | Drew Turner | John Carroll | Sr. | Mayfield Hts., Ohio |
| T | Caleb Riggleman | Marietta | Sr. | Beverly, W.Va. |
| First team defense | ||||
| DE | Harry Henschler | UW-Whitewater | Sr. | Janesville, Wis. |
| DT | Dillon Rademaker | Wartburg | Sr. | Greene, Iowa |
| DT | Austin Dean | Brockport | Sr. | Masonville, N.Y. |
| DE | Frankie Feaster | Muhlenberg | Jr. | Montvale, N.J. |
| LB | Eric Stevenson | Wheaton (Ill.) | Sr. | Lewisville, Texas |
| LB | Derrick Jennings Jr. | UW-Oshkosh | Sr. | DeForest, Wis. |
| LB | Danny Robinson | Mount Union | Sr. | Massillon, Ohio |
| CB | Louis Berry | Mount Union | Sr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| S | Max Jackson | St. John's | Sr. | St. Paul, Minn. |
| S | Jefferson Fritz | Mary Hardin-Baylor | So. | Kaufman, Texas |
| CB | Cal Lewellyn | Centre | Jr. | Louisville, Ky. |
| First team specialists | ||||
| K | Derik Judka | North Central (Ill.) | Fr. | Burbank, Ill. |
| P | Michael Raczak | Widener | Jr. | Jamison, Pa. |
| RET | Aaron Sims | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Fr. | Cameron, Texas |
| ST | Kyle Hogan | Ohio Wesleyan | Jr. | Centerburg, Ohio |
| Second team offense | ||||
| QB | David Tammaro | Johns Hopkins | Jr. | Chantilly, Va. |
| RB | Josh Parks | St. Thomas | Sr. | Chisago Lakes, Minn. |
| RB | Alex Peete | UW-Whitewater | So. | Ringwood, Ill. |
| WR | Will Gillach | St. John's | Sr. | Lindstrom, Minn. |
| WR | Mike Panzarino | FDU-Florham | Sr. | Fairfield, N.J. |
| TE | Danny Disbrow | John Carroll | Sr. | Avon Lake, Ohio |
| T | Caleb Ferdilus | Brockport | Sr. | Pomona, N.Y. |
| G | Alex Wendorf | UW-Oshkosh | Sr. | Watertown, Wis. |
| C | Matt Beck | St. Thomas | Jr. | Plymouth, Minn. |
| G | Andrew Houck | Salisbury | Sr. | Salisbury, Md. |
| T | Riley Hartman | Frostburg State | Sr. | Leesburg, Va. |
| Second team defense | ||||
| DE | Andrew Roesch | Mount Union | Jr. | Avon, Ohio |
| DT | Joey Longoria | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Jr. | Pearland, Texas |
| DT | Bryson Lamboy | Berry | Sr. | Cave Springs, Ga. |
| DE | Jimmy Thomas | John Carroll | Sr. | Buffalo, N.Y. |
| LB | Sam Romanski | UW-Eau Claire | Jr. | Wausau, Wis. |
| LB | Matt Gurgone | St. Norbert | Sr. | Orland Park, Ill. |
| LB | Isaiah Turner | FDU-Florham | Sr. | Rockaway, N.J. |
| CB | Reginald Cole | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Houston, Texas |
| S | Trevor Staley | Illinois Wesleyan | Sr. | Lake Zurich, Ill. |
| S | Austin White | Mount Union | Sr. | Wadsworth, Ohio |
| CB | Famus Hasty | UW-Whitewater | Sr. | Naperville, Ill. |
| Second team specialists | ||||
| K | Spenser Thompson-Meyers | St. Norbert | Sr. | San Ramon, Calif. |
| P | Elias Deeb | Chapman | Jr. | Lakewood, Calif. |
| RET | Elijah Rehm | Rowan | Jr. | Clayton, N.J. |
| ST | Jake Smith | Cortland | Sr. | Albany, N.Y. |
| Third team offense | ||||
| QB | Broc Rutter | North Central (Ill.) | Jr. | Naperville, Ill. |
| RB | Lamar Carswell | Trine | Sr. | Toledo, Ohio |
| RB | De'Eric Bell | Guilford | Sr. | Jackson, Ga. |
| WR | Andrew Wolf | Washington & Jefferson | So. | Ashland, Ohio |
| WR | Alex Kemp | Wesley | Sr. | Magnolia, Del. |
| TE | Jacob Maher | Worcester State | Jr. | Marshfield, Mass. |
| T | D.J. Coker | Rhodes | Sr. | Buford, Ga. |
| G | Sharmore Clarke | North Central (Ill.) | So. | Oak Park, Ill. |
| C | Nick Bainter | Springfield | Jr. | East Bridgewater, Mass. |
| G | Greg Castle | Randolph-Macon | Sr. | Kenley, N.C. |
| T | Colton Hall | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Liberty Hill, Texas |
| Third team defense | ||||
| DE | Michael Nobile | Delaware Valley | Fr. | Brick, N.J. |
| DT | David Danhauer | St. Thomas | Sr. | Barrington, Ill. |
| DT | Conner Bogard | John Carroll | Jr. | Cleveland, Ohio |
| DE | Nathan Brinker | St. John's | Sr. | Avon, Minn. |
| LB | Trey Williams | Mount Union | Jr. | Cardington, Ohio |
| LB | Mauro Altamura | Montclair State | Sr. | Hasbrouck Heights, N.J. |
| LB | Dejon Brooks | Averett | Sr. | Clinton, Md. |
| CB | Marcus Winters | Trine | Sr. | Toledo, Ohio |
| S | Duke Mackle | Linfield | Sr. | San Diego, Calif. |
| S | Pat Minogue | Ithaca | Sr. | Manorville, N.Y. |
| CB | Gabe Brown | Mount Union | Jr. | Plant City, Fla. |
| Third team specialists | ||||
| K | Nick DiCairano | Endicott | Jr. | Trumbull, Conn. |
| P | Austin Baker | Heidelberg | Sr. | Green Springs, Ohio |
| RET | Jeffery Barnett | Trine | Sr. | Fremont, Ohio |
| ST | Brady Payne | Howard Payne | So. | Little Elm, Texas |
| Honorable mention offense | ||||
| QB | Matt Sacia | Wartburg | Sr. | Eldridge, Iowa |
| RB | Nas Smith | Alfred | So. | Auburn, N.Y. |
| RB | Tanner Clark | Marietta | Jr. | Caldwell, Ohio |
| WR | Alvin Johnson | Puget Sound | Jr. | Tacoma, Wash. |
| WR | Brad Bonomini | Franklin | Sr. | Lawrenceburg, Ind. |
| TE | Dan Allen | Delaware Valley | Jr. | Philadelphia, Pa. |
| T | Tyler Adamson | Whitworth | Sr. | Oak Harbor, Wash. |
| G | Lane Smith | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Franklin, Texas |
| C | Brendan Mulholland | Marietta | Sr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| G | Joe Figueroa | Johns Hopkins | Jr. | River Vale, N.J. |
| T | Kyle Rademaker | St. Norbert | Sr. | Eden Prairie, Minn. |
| Honorable mention defense | ||||
| DE | Nick Giorgio | Springfield | Sr. | Cumberland, R.I. |
| DT | David O'Gorman | UW-Whitewater | Sr. | Watertown, Wis. |
| DT | D'On Coofer | Rhodes | Sr. | Goodlettsville, Tenn. |
| DE | Kyle Kilgore | Bethel | Sr. | Cottage Grove, Minn. |
| LB | Jalen Martin | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Round Rock, Texas |
| LB | Jack Reilly | Union | Sr. | Dumont, N.J. |
| LB | Ryan Slager | Grinnell | Sr. | Orland Park, Ill. |
| CB | Rashad Baker | Brockport | Sr. | Greenburgh, N.Y. |
| S | Cole Yoder | UW-Oshkosh | Sr. | Oshkosh, Wis. |
| S | Dillon Nelson | Manchester | Sr. | Fairland, Ind. |
| CB | Obasi Dees | Cal Lutheran | Jr. | Antioch, Calif. |
| Honorable mention specialists | ||||
| K | Kyle Hackett | Hobart | So. | Charlton, Mass. |
| P | Zach Warcola | TCNJ | Jr. | Mendham, N.J. |
| RET | Rae Millsap | Hardin-Simmons | Fr. | Abilene, Texas |
| ST | Justin Prostinak | UW-Whitewater | Jr. | Milwaukee, Wis. |