Dec 15, 2007
Offensive Player of the Year: Justin Beaver,
RB, UW-Whitewater
Defensive Player of the Year: Jerrell Freeman,
LB, Mary Hardin-Baylor
Coach of the Year: Lance Leipold,
UW-Whitewater
| First Team | Second Team | |
| Offense | ||
| QB | Greg Micheli, Jr., Mount Union | Bobby Swallow, Jr., Washington and Jefferson |
| RB | Justin Beaver, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Jarvis Thrasher, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| RB | Nate Kmic, Jr., Mount Union | Andy Moriarty, Sr., UW-Oshkosh |
| WR | Jack Phelan, Jr., Hartwick | Jake Allen, Sr., Mississippi College |
| WR | Pierre Garcon, Sr., Mount Union | Royce Winford, Jr., Augsburg |
| TE | Nolan Swett, Sr., Colorado College | Bryan Bergman, Sr., Carthage |
| T | Brennan Fortune, Sr., St. John Fisher | Cuyler Groth, Jr., Brockport State |
| G | Derek Blanchard, Sr., Mount Union | Jordan Hataway, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| C | Eric Safran, Sr., Mount Union | Brent Allen, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| G | Jon Stavast, Sr., Luther | Michael Robinson, Sr., Trinity (Conn.) |
| T | Caleb Woodall, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Dave Erdman, Jr., Wesley |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Bryan Robinson, Sr., Wesley | Jarrell Chandler, Jr., Salisbury |
| DT | Pat McCullough, Sr., Mount Union | Joe King, Sr., New Jersey |
| DT | Ryan Ogrizovich, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Nick Gunderson, Jr., St. John's |
| DE | Mike Czerwien, Sr., Waynesburg | Ken Bevington, Jr., John Carroll |
| LB | Jerrell Freeman, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Chris Gustafson, Sr., Cornell |
| LB | Adi Pynenberg, Sr., Wabash | Lenny Trusnik, Sr., Ohio Northern |
| LB | Kyle Follweiler, Sr., Wilkes | A.J. Raebel, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| CB | Pete Ittersagen, Jr., Wheaton | James Starks, Sr., Capital |
| S | Matt Kostelnik, Sr., Mount Union | Jay Tully., Sr., Whitworth |
| S | Brandon Carr, Sr., Bethel | Derrick Williams, Jr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| CB | Steve Stepnick, Sr., St. John Fisher | Ben Farley, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Jeff Schebler, So., UW-Whitewater | Joel Munoz, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| P | Alex Groh, So., Occidental | Kevin Soflkiancs, Sr., Baldwin-Wallace |
| RET | Larry Beavers, Jr., Wesley | Pete Ittersagen, Jr., Wheaton |
| Third Team | Honorable Mention | |
| Offense | ||
| QB | Chad Rupp, Jr., Franklin | Tim Connell, Sr., Central |
| RB | Mike Pennewell, So., Wesley | Robert Heller, Fr., Waynesburg |
| RB | Vinson Hendrix, So., Alfred | Tyler Sherden, Sr., Luther |
| WR | Drew Smith, Sr., Hampden-Sydney | Luke Dillon, Sr., Defiance |
| WR | Horace Gant, Sr., St. Olaf | P.J. Theisen, Sr., St. Thomas |
| TE | Matt Johnson, Sr., Muhlenberg | Jon Lanouette, Jr., Wesley |
| T | Brandon Bennett, Sr., Willamette | Grant Weller, Sr., Concordia-Moorhead |
| G | Don Kasper, Sr., North Central | Randy Gyllin, Sr., UW-La Crosse |
| C | Tyler Hykel, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Andrew Salvato, Sr., St. John's |
| G | Nick Hartmann, Sr., Coast Guard | Matt Houy, Jr., Washington and Jefferson |
| T | Adam Persing, Sr., Capital | James Arnold, Sr., Hardin-Simmons |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Jay Arndt, Sr., St. Norbert | William Dewease, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| DT | Jonathan Spring, Sr., Capital | Casey Younger, Sr., Millsaps |
| DT | Tom Pinto, Sr., Curry | LeeRon Boykin, So., North Carolina Wesleyan |
| DE | Andrew Eisentrout, Sr., Pacific Lutheran | Ryan Yaple, Sr., Lycoming |
| LB | Eric Dube, Sr., Dickinson | Courtney Pearson, Jr., Tri-State |
| LB | Greg Altmaier, Sr., Central | Adam Hay, Jr., Centre |
| LB | Tom Brew, Sr., Case Western Reserve | Erik Woodring, Sr., Middlebury |
| CB | James Alexander, Sr., Hobart | Chet Turner, Jr., Wesley |
| S | Dave Wicklund, Sr., UW-Eau Claire | Matt Christ, Jr., Albright |
| S | Michael Terranova, Jr., Olivet | Bo Osburn, Sr., Illinois Wesleyan |
| CB | Guy Dierikx, Sr., Central | Orlando Brown, Sr., Widener |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Alex Lachman, Fr., Johns Hopkins | Scott Birkhofer, Jr., Linfield |
| P | Jesse Harms, Sr., Coast Guard | Ryan Patten, So., Olivet |
| RET | Jason Chier, Jr., Ithaca | Tom Breitbach, Jr., Coe |