Dec 15, 2017
D3football.com Offensive Player of the Year: Brett Kasper, QB, UW-Oshkosh
D3football.com Defensive Player of the Year: Mamadou Soumahoro, DE, Berry
D3football.com Coach of the Year: Vince Kehres, Mount Union
| First team Offense | ||||
| Pos. | First Team | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| QB | Brett Kasper | UW-Oshkosh | Sr. | Two Rivers, Wis |
| RB | Roger Walker | Marietta | Sr. | Palm Bay, Fla. |
| RB | Austin Breunig | North Central (Ill.) | Sr. | Sandwich, Ill. |
| WR | Jesse Zubik | Washington & Jefferson | Sr. | Sewickley, Pa. |
| WR | Nick Holcomb | UW-La Crosse | Sr. | Germantown, Wis. |
| TE | Zach Lindquist | Wheaton (Ill.) | Sr. | Mahtomedi, Minn. |
| T | Brock Riggs | Heidelberg | Sr. | Tiffin, Ohio |
| G | Christian Walsh | Frostburg State | Sr. | Magnolia, N.J. |
| C | Vic Rodriguez | Hardin-Simmons | Sr. | Mesquite, Texas |
| G | Tyler Powers | UW-Oshkosh | Jr. | Greenville, Wis. |
| T | Derek Schipper | Wartburg | Sr. | Ackley, Iowa |
| Defense | ||||
| DE | Mamadou Soumahoro | Berry | Sr. | Lawrenceville, Ga. |
| DT | Haston Adams | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Beckville, Texas |
| DT | Mike Vidal | Mount Union | Sr. | Miami, Fla. |
| DE | Elijah Berry | Mount Union | Sr. | Dublin, Ohio |
| LB | Jason Farlow | Linfield | Sr. | Ventura, Calif. |
| LB | Jordan Hassan | Illinois Wesleyan | Sr. | Wheaton, Ill. |
| LB | Derrick Jennings | UW-Oshkosh | Jr. | DeForest, Wis. |
| CB | Michael Joseph | Dubuque | Sr. | Oswego, Ill. |
| S | Jake O’Connell | Brockport | Sr. | Rochester, N.Y. |
| S | Shawn Miller | Delaware Valley | Sr. | Laurel, Del. |
| CB | Jordan Powell | Widener | Jr. | Morristown, N.J. |
| Specialists | ||||
| K | Cole Westberry | Averett | So. | Youngsville, N.C. |
| P | Austin Baker | Heidelberg | Jr. | Clyde, Ohio |
| RET | Bryce Wilkerson | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Tyler, Texas |
| ST | Dan Appley | Cortland | Jr. | Herkimer, N.Y. |
| AP | De’Eric Bell | Guilford | Jr. | Jackson, Ga. |
Second team Offense |
||||
| QB | Chase Burton | Franklin | Sr. | Corydon, Ind. |
| RB | Chad Johnson | Concordia-Moorhead | Sr. | Glyndon, Minn. |
| RB | John Smith | Husson | Sr. | Fayetteville, Ga. |
| WR | Justin Hill | Mount Union | So. | Circleville, Ohio |
| WR | Riley Brockway | Wartburg | Sr. | Postville, Iowa |
| TE | Matt Christenson | St. Thomas | Sr. | Nicollet, Minn. |
| T | Joe Fehrle | North Central (Ill.) | Sr. | Rockford, Ill. |
| G | Justin Fairfield | Hope | Sr. | N. Muskegon, Mich. |
| C | Ty Summers | UW-Oshkosh | Sr. | Lake Villa, Ill. |
| G | Chris Osier | Washington & Lee | Sr. | Lebanon, Tenn. |
| T | Corbin Campitelli | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Dallas, Texas |
| Defense | ||||
| DE | Ajay Fanene | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Riverside, Calif. |
| DT | Niles Scott | Frostburg State | Sr. | Elkton, Md. |
| DT | Austin Jochum | St. Thomas | Sr. | Foley, Minn. |
| DE | Casey Kerschner | Widener | Sr. | Adamstown, Pa. |
| LB | Darin Hungerford | Kean | Sr. | Dumfries, Va. |
| LB | Mason McKenrick | John Carroll | Sr. | Mentor, Ohio |
| LB | Charlie Dear | Mount Union | Sr. | Massillon, Ohio |
| CB | Gabe Brown | Mount Union | So. | Plant City, Fla. |
| S | Drew Fitzmorris | Carnegie Mellon | Sr. | Omaha, Neb. |
| S | Isaac Seering | St. Thomas | Sr. | Green Bay, Wis. |
| CB | Kris Brown | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Sealy, Texas |
| Specialists | ||||
| K | Cameron Cook | Adrian | Sr. | Linden, Mich. |
| P | Tyler Kohman | Carnegie Mellon | Sr. | Pataskala, Ohio |
| RET | Dakota Nelson | Manchester | Sr. | Fairland, Ind. |
| ST | Nick Swore | Northwestern (Minn.) | Jr. | Grand Rapids, Mich. |
Third Team Offense |
||||
| QB | Michael Whitley | Lakeland | Sr. | Vidalia, La. |
| RB | Joey Valdivia | Lake Forest | Sr. | Grayslake, Ill. |
| RB | Jordan Wilcox | Springfield | Sr. | Saratoga Springs, N.Y. |
| WR | Sam Mentkowski | UW-Oshkosh | Sr. | Greenfield, Wis. |
| WR | Nate Hodapp | Hendrix | Sr. | Mansfield, Texas |
| TE | Ryan Curtiss | Muhlenberg | So. | Franklin Lakes, N.J. |
| T | Matt Gono | Wesley | Sr. | Cinnaminson, N.J. |
| G | Dan Greenheck | St. John’s | So. | St. Paul, Minn. |
| C | Cole Parrish | Mount Union | Sr. | Creedmore, N.C. |
| G | Alejandro Briseno | Texas Lutheran | Sr. | Brownsville, Texas |
| T | Adan Barrientos | Brockport | Sr. | Mount Kisco, N.Y. |
| Defense | ||||
| DE | Harry Henschler | UW-Whitewater | Jr. | Janesville, Wis. |
| DT | Montel Lee | Ferrum | Sr. | Andalusia, Ala. |
| DT | Nick Jacobsen | UW-River Falls | Sr. | Prescott, Wis. |
| DE | Chase Greenlee | Wheaton (Ill.) | Sr. | Columbus, Ohio |
| LB | Ty Parsons | East Texas Baptist | Sr. | Rowlett, Texas |
| LB | Zach Schmerge | Ohio Northern | Sr. | Wapakoneta, Ohio |
| LB | Tevin Jones | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Jr. | Belton, Texas |
| CB | O’Shea Anderson | Washington & Jefferson | Sr. | Rochester, Pa. |
| S | Trevor Staley | Illinois Wesleyan | Jr. | Lake Zurich, Ill. |
| S | Vic Smith, Jr. | Guilford | Sr. | Lakeland, Fla. |
| CB | Todd Jeter | Westminster (Pa.) | Sr. | Monroeville, Pa. |
| Specialists | ||||
| K | Willy Warne | Linfield | So. | Vancover, Wash. |
| P | Johnny Davidson | Washington U. | So. | Inverness, Ill. |
| RET | Dom Todarello | UW-Oshkosh | Jr. | Hartland, Wis. |
| ST | Jean Gabriel | Husson | Sr. | Lake Worth, Fla. |
Honorable Mention Offense |
||||
| QB | Joe Germinerio | Brockport | So. | Wynantskill, N.Y. |
| RB | Jaquan Hemphill | Hardin-Simmons | Jr. | Coleman, Texas |
| RB | Josh Breece | Washington & Lee | Fr. | Lorton, Va. |
| WR | Mike Breuler | Wesleyan | Sr. | Hamden, Conn. |
| WR | Cam Johnson | Hampden-Sydney | Sr. | Dillwyn, Va. |
| TE | Jacob Maher | Worcester State | So. | Marshfield, Mass. |
| T | Matt Fitchet | Mount Union | Sr. | Conneaut, Ohio |
| G | Riley Owens | Hardin-Simmons | Sr. | Abilene, Texas |
| C | Mark Sanchez | Brockport | Sr. | Castle Hill, N.Y. |
| G | Nolan Schuler | George Fox | Sr. | Bakersfield, Calif. |
| T | Ben McFall | UW-Whitewater | Sr. | Rewey, Wis. |
| Defense | ||||
| DE | Mike Riley | Rose-Hulman | Jr. | Naperville, Ill. |
| DT | Vince Char | Widener | Jr. | Southampton, Pa. |
| DT | Austin Crow | Heidelberg | Sr. | Westerville, Ohio |
| DE | Caleb Dalzell | George Fox | Jr. | Gresham, Ore. |
| LB | Max Garrett | Washington & Lee | Sr. | Fairfield, Conn. |
| LB | A.J. Licata | Alfred | Sr. | Lake View, N.Y. |
| LB | Charles Riga | George Fox | Jr. | Portland, Ore. |
| CB | Nik Kelly | Southwestern | Sr. | League City, Texas |
| S | Fred Hardgrove | Otterbein | So. | Columbus, Ohio |
| S | Max Jackson | St. John's | Jr. | St. Paul, Minn. |
| CB | Justus Drakeford | Christopher Newport | Sr. | Warrenton, Va. |
| Specialists | ||||
| K | Alex Louthan | Mount Union | Sr. | Loganville, Ga. |
| P | Stephen Adams | Delaware Valley | Jr. | Bordentown, N.J. |
| RET | Preston Addo | Stevenson | Sr. | Gaithersburg, Md. |