| First Team | Second Team | |
| Offense | ||
| QB | Brad Boyle, Sr., Coe | Alex Tanney, Sr., Monmouth |
| RB | Levell Coppage, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Justin Autera, Jr., Cortland State |
| RB | Clinton Orr, Jr., Albion | Ben Guiles, Sr., Lebanon Valley |
| WR | Josh McKee, Sr., Wittenberg | Jasper Collins, Jr., Mount Union |
| WR | Daniel Passafiume, Sr., Hanover | Michael Zweifel, Sr., Dubuque |
| TE | Kyle Fiedorowicz, North Central (Ill.) | Shawn Evans, Sr., Lewis and Clark |
| T | Corey Balcerzak, Sr., St. John Fisher | Chad Vandergriff, Sr., St. Thomas |
| G | Billy Castro, Sr., Cortland State | Mitch Elliot, Sr., Bethel |
| C | Brett Ekkens, Sr., Mount Union | Ed Rodger, Sr., Johns Hopkins |
| G | John Fitzgibbons, Sr., Washington and Lee | Lewis Brown, Sr., DePauw |
| T | Koby Parker, Sr., Hardin-Simmons | Weston Kitley, Jr., Wabash |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Mike Jaskowski, Sr., Delaware Valley | Frank Weymiller, Jr., Coe |
| DT | Kevin Ferber, Sr., Amherst | Rian Younker, Jr., Cal Lutheran |
| DT | Dan Terhune, Sr., Wooster | Mike Raplee, Jr., Alfred |
| DE | Chris Mayes, Sr., Wesley | Kenneth Cobb, Sr., Muhlenberg |
| LB | Mike Asiedu, Sr., Wesley | Jeff Morgan, Sr., Wesley |
| LB | Kyle McGivney, Sr., Luther | Greg Arnold, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| LB | Patrick McDonough, Sr., Muhlenberg | Devin Worthington, So., Hobart |
| CB | Chris Greenwood, Sr., Albion | Jared Millikian, Sr., Anderson |
| S | Drew Fisher, Sr., Linfield | Josh McLeod, Sr., North Central (Ill.) |
| S | Ray Bierbach, Sr., Lycoming | Will Morris, Sr., McMurry |
| CB | Luis Villavicencio, Sr., Cal Lutheran | Dwayne Hollis, Jr., N.C. Wesleyan |
| Specialists | ||
| ST/AP | Jonathan Koop, Jr., Wabash | Nick Clark, Sr., Alfred |
| K | David Prizzia, Sr., Hampden-Sydney | Auburn Jimenez, So., Macalester |
| P | Joe Liscio, Sr., Montclair State | Robby Salmon, Sr., Wartburg |
| RET | Laquan Robinson, So., Widener | Wes Chamblee, Sr., Wabash |